Lleras Law
Minister of Interior and Justice, Germain Vargas Lleras, submitted yesterday to Congress a bill to regulate access to content by Internet without complying with the rules of copyright. In short, the bill means you may be penalized with imprisonment those who use the Internet for items such as movies, music, programs or books without paying the copyright, and to punish ISPs that lend themselves to this piracy with blocks of their pages, suspension of access or simply unsubscribing their services.
This article Carlos Forero, on page II Plana (recomendadísimo of this house) contains an analysis of 8 points that the author proposes to oppose the project. Beyond platitudes as this country has worse crimes by los cuales preocuparse, o que la medida fue planteada desde el Mininterior sin consultar con un ente capacitado como lo es el Ministerio de Tecnologías de la Información y Comunicaciones, existen dos puntos de esta crítica que tomaré y desarrollaré para realizar la mía.
El primero: la norma induce directamente a asumir que todo el que descarga una canción o un libro lo hace pirateando. Ignora, de esta forma, la posición del freeware, el código libre y el copyleft: el ministro Vargas Lleras parece ignorar, a partir del lobby, que existe una comunidad de artistas que crean sus obras fuera del alcance de Sayco y Acinpro. Súmese a esto la exigencia de Sayco, donde uno literalmente no puede tener un radio o un a computer with speakers disconnected and damaged business without paying, because it gets right there evader copyright. The regulations in this topic, especially as regards music, it is extremely backward and out of step with the technological realities. And cost overruns by these rules are outrageous. I saw a tweet about it, according to which a book published in Argentina comes with 75% of cost overruns to a bookstore by Colombian customs, taxes and royalties.
That is another matter. Many of the sources of piracy actually exist because there is more to do: in this country, offering musical and non-academic literature is too limited. For example, I flipped Bogota midfielder Harry Turtledove looking for work, and have not found. Likewise, in Colombia there is no Amazon, Barnes and Noble, iTunes, Netflix or another service that allows purchase music, books, movies or TV shows online, without problems. The closest is the National Library with your purchase of books online, a good project, but limited by what is in their own shelves and warehouses.
Finally, this rule has proved to be unpopular. I am opposed to it, as I said above, not the problems of copyright and digital anarchy. As I put on Twitter, I support a rule that penalizes piracy when there are alternatives valid. The momentary situation lends itself to lead to break the law to those who need or want something beyond the limits of Sayco, large publishers, record labels or film studios. And certainly it is true that piracy has been held, the country can not continue in that vein policy of considering guilty to all in advance, without first finding out their motives. The rules must adapt to reality, and Lleras law seems to adapt reality to a standard. In that, I hope that can provide collaboration MinTic the Interior Minister, to prevent Vargas Lleras, who was doing well as a minister, commits an error similar to SINDE Law in Spain and the political setback this will involved. So that's why no more, thinking about the elections of 2014, Vargas Lleras should reconsider the rigidity of their position.
0 comments:
Post a Comment